December 10, 2023
Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

Over the past 15 years, the Chinese government has made significant efforts to promote innovation-driven growth through industrial policy and corporate subsidies. In a new study, researchers examined government subsidies to businesses in China to determine whether they are making firms more productive. The study found that China’s rising wave of subsidizing businesses has had limited effect on promoting the firms’ productivity.

The study, by researchers at Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) and ShanghaiTech University, appears in the Journal of Comparative Economics.

“Many countries have criticized China for playing favorites with indigenous Chinese firms when handing out subsidies, suggesting that these firms are given an unfair advantage over foreign firms, as well as small and mid-size enterprises, in the race to dominate technological business,” says Lee G. Branstetter, professor of economics and at CMU’s Heinz College, who co-authored the study. “Yet many of these claims have not been studied.”

In their study, researchers used firm-level data that has not before been fully analyzed: Since 2007, companies listed on any of China’s stock exchanges have been required to disclose all direct subsidies received, along with a brief description of the nature of these subsidies. Based on these disclosures, the study found that the total amount of direct government subsidies to Chinese-listed companies increased more than seven-fold from 2007 to 2018, from $4 billion to $29 billion.

The study found little evidence that Chinese government subsidies boost firms’ productivity; if anything, the evidence suggested that direct subsidies tended to flow to less productive firms rather than more productive firms. In addition, overall, the receipt of direct government subsidies negatively correlated with subsequent growth in firms’ productivity from 2007 to 2018.

Even subsidies given by the government in the name of promoting research and development or innovation, or upgrading industrial equipment did not show any statistically significant effects on firms’ subsequent productivity growth.

“While the Chinese government has articulated a clear ambition to promote innovation-driven growth through the use of industrial policy and corporate subsidies, our research suggests that there is little evidence that it has been able to consistently pick or create winners,” notes Guangwei Li, assistant professor at Shanghai Tech University’s School of Entrepreneurship and Management, who coauthored the study.

“Subsidies seemed to be allocated to less productive firms, and the relative of ‘ receiving these subsidies appeared to decline further after disbursement.”

The study did find that government subsidies supported slightly higher levels of employment, at least temporarily. The authors suggest that this is consistent with the view that political and social considerations might outweigh efficiency considerations in the government’s allocation of direct subsidies.

Among the study’s limitations, the authors note that their data on subsidies are limited, reflecting only one of the many policy instruments the Chinese government is using to shape the nation’s industrial evolution. In addition, they characterize their analysis as largely descriptive.

More information:
Lee G. Branstetter et al, Picking winners? Government subsidies and firm productivity in China, Journal of Comparative Economics (2023). DOI: 10.1016/j.jce.2023.06.004

Chinese government’s corporate subsidies have had little effect on firms’ productivity (2023, October 10)
retrieved 10 October 2023

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

How to Get TikTok Coins Effortlessly
Les secrets de l’obtention de pièces gratuites sur TikTok
Boost Your TikTok Influence with Free Coins
Legit Ways to Get TikTok Coins for Free
Réussir la récolte de pièces TikTok : Astuces
Free TikTok Coins: The Future of Social Media
How to Get TikTok Coins Effortlessly
Améliorez votre expérience TikTok avec des pièces gratuites
Mastering TikTok Coins: Expert Insights
TikTok Coin Generator Safety Tips
La science de la récolte de pièces sur TikTok
The Secret Sauce to TikTok Coin Generation
TikTok Coin Farming: Tips for Success
استراتيجيات نجاح في جمع العملات TikTok بشكل يومي
TikTok Coin Farming: What You Need to Know
Free TikTok Coins: Where to Find Them
مولدي العملات TikTok: نصائح للاستفادة القصوى
Unlimited TikTok Coins: Myth or Reality?
TikTok Coin Generators: What to Watch Out For
Impulsa tu Cuenta de TikTok con Monedas Gratis
TikTok Coin Generators: What to Watch Out For
TikTok Coin Farming: What You Need to Know
Des pièces illimitées sur TikTok : Mythe ou réalité ?
The Science of TikTok Coin Farming
Free TikTok Coins: Insider Secrets

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *